Blog Post

Is it ethical to publish League Tables?

The Irish Independent published, what they called, a definitive league table of the best schools in Ireland, based on 7 years of data. It was based on the percentage of students that went on to third level from secondary school. Schools where close to 100% of their students went on to third level over the 7 years, were deemed to be the best schools in Ireland and today’s newspaper was full of little vox pop articles from the schools explaining how they managed it. The problem is that it’s all nonsense. League tables are possibly one of the most dangerous and threatening thing to be associated with our education system.

Even the Independent concedes that one should take the data with a pinch of salt in their article and even claims that the information is highly flawed and doesn’t give the full story about how good a school is. They are right on both scores. However, they admit that the data in these tables is taken seriously by parents and affects their choice of school. Therefore, is it right to publish tables like these? Furthermore, are we in danger now with POD that primary schools are going to be brought into this incredibly rudimentary measure of a school’s success?

While there are many flaws in these tables, my favourite flaw of all is that any of the new second level schools that have opened will achieve a score of 0% and therefore, by default, must be bottom of these league tables. If we bring this back to primary schools using the same criteria, on paper, my own school would be bottom of the pile for the reason that none of the pupils that have been through my school are old enough to have gone on to third level. Does this make my school the worst performing school in the county? (I’d like to think not!)

However, the big problem for schools, both primary and secondary, is that league tables are here to stay. It’s inevitable. Everyone either loves them or hates them. Even though I can see them for what they are, I still had to check where my secondary school featured in the running and where all the Carlow secondary schools featured. The only thing we can probably do is figure out a way to make the playing field level and bring in variables that balance out the rudimentary one.

This is a difficult task as education is an holistic profession with many variables that are not measurable in numbers. Students’ test results do not correlate with quality of teachers. For example, two students could view a C1 in honours English as an underachievement or an overachievement depending on their circumstances and possibly because of a good or bad teacher. We need to figure out some way to measure the quality of the teaching based on something other than student results as it does not give a true reflection. This applies equally at primary level.

We also need to look at other factors in schools – what sorts of extra-curricular activities are on offer, what type of parental involvement is happening, how are pupils treated, how happy are the staff, how happy are the pupils, how effective is the leadership, what sort of role does the Board of Management have, and so on.

While simply rating schools on the basis of entry to third level, is bordering on being unethical, this obviously doesn’t stop newspapers from printing them. It’s easy for them to grab a tiny piece of flawed data and create their league tables. Gathering the more useful information is hard. It may even be impossible, though I don’t think this is the case. We’re coming closer to the day when primary schools will be rated on similar grounds of student results in standardised tests so now is the time to give the journalists better data to use. If they’re going to rate us anyway, we may as well give them relevant information.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts Predictions for 2017

Every year, I try to predict what the big stories will be in primary

How to make denominational schools more inclusive

Around 96% of Irish primary schools are under the patronage of a religious body,

Primary Schools: Inclusive or Tolerant?

As most people know, there are a number of parents in Ireland who have

Infographic of Survey on Inclusiveness

I developed an infographic based on the data received from my survey on how

How inclusive are Catholic Schools?

Recently, The Irish Independent carried an article with the headline, Catholic Schools are as inclusive

The Mathematics of Patronage and Pluralism

Between 96% and 98% of Irish primary schools are denominational in patronage, which means

2016 Predictions

As we come to the last day of year, it is traditional at to make predictions

What will removing Rule 68 actually do?

One of the rules of National Schools that has been causing much debate over

Multidenominational: A long word, long-abused

The education landscape used to be an easy one to maneuver. Between the 1920s

Can the new NCCA Ethics Curriculum work in Ireland?

It always strikes me as odd the stories about primary education that get noticed

Why Pluralism in Education Doesn’t Work

I was listening to a debate on the radio about the Angelus last week.

Thoughts on the Digital Strategy

The Digital Strategy for Schools 2015-2020 is the latest attempt by the government to

Should we be Celebrating the 1916 Rising?

Earlier this week, two army officials came to my school to present us with

An Alternative to Droichead

Following my blog post on Droichead last week, I thought I might expand on my

Droichead: A bridge too far

Droichead is a new model of induction and probation for newly qualified teachers, which

Burren National School: A symbol of the divestment process

Today, Educate Together announced that the proposed new Educate Together school in Castlebar was

Where do unbaptised children fit in?

I’ve been following the recent discussions about unbaptised children accessing primary education over the last

Who are the role models in primary schools?

Last weekend, I was part of a panel at the Excited Festival of Learning

Why We’re Voting Yes to Marriage Equality

Commenting on referenda is not something that we generally do at but the

Should schools be allowed to discriminate?

The headline grabber from the INTO congress was Jan O’Sullivan’s announcement that new enrollment

Denominational Schools and the Upcoming Marriage Referendum

The upcoming referendum on marriage equality has sparked some conversation among teachers who work

Why we don’t need to start teaching coding in primary schools

Ciaran Cannon is one of the most innovative politicians I know and he is

Primary Schools and Broadband: The biggest issue in education today?

Following on from a conversation on the wonderful CESI list, I thought I would

What books would you recommend for a primary school teacher?

Facebook is awash with challenges from ice-buckets to listing how you’re grateful for the

A short guide to religion in primary schools

Over the last number of years, the population of Ireland has changed. One of the

Why we should care about Ireland’s Human Rights Record in Education

Last week, the Irish government was given a major slap on the wrist for

Fitness to teach is all about motivating teachers to love their job-Part 2

Self-actualisation and flow In my first post on performance-related pay, I spoke about the process

Cutting the cost of school uniforms? Why not cut them altogether?

Irish parents are to be balloted on school uniforms in the coming weeks in

How to save the Irish language

One of the most popular conversations I have with non-teachers is about the Irish

Do we need Teaching Council 2.0?

It hasn’t been the best couple of months for the Teaching Council. Established six

Douglas Adams, The Fourth R and Learning

I was happy to see that technology was on the agenda at the annual

12 reasons to have Computerised Roll Books

Imagine it’s 11:30am on June 30th.  What are you doing?  Apart from trying to

What have the Teaching Council ever done for us?

Have recently discovered Inside Education on 103.2 Dublin City FM. Simon introduced me to

Why Blogging is Best – a digiteach article

I was asked to write a follow-up article about my workshop at this year’s

Ask Us A Question

You will get a notification email when Knowledgebase answerd/updated!

+ = Verify Human or Spambot ?