Primary Schools: Inclusive or Tolerant?

As most people know, there are a number of parents in Ireland who have been in the media lately claiming that they cannot enrol their children in their local school as they do not have a Baptismal Certificate. However, in the vast majority of schools, this is not the case. The Catholic church claim that most of their schools do not have a Catholics-First enrollment policy and that they welcome and include all children of all and no faiths into their schools. The word “inclusive” is most commonly used by denominational schools to describe themselves. A couple of weeks ago, I decided to survey Irish primary teachers about how inclusive their school really is. I asked questions to teachers of common problems faced by minority and no faith families. None of the questions were loaded and simply asked teachers how they dealt with these problems. I published the survey results last week without comment.

When I began teaching, the word “tolerant” was used to describe how denominational schools dealt with children from different backgrounds. It wasn’t a particularly nice word but it described the situation well. Schools had to accept enrollments from outside the fold and they had to allow them to opt-out of religious instruction. When it came to prayers or visits to church, these children had to be tolerated by allowing them do something else where possible.

The results of my survey demonstrate to me that nothing much has changed except that the word “tolerant” has been replaced with a new word: “inclusive.” It appears that practices have not changed at all. Being completely honest, I was quite shocked by the findings. Before I begin, the purpose of this article is not to criticise schools; it is to criticise the education system, which has allowed children to be excluded from, at worst, certain schools and at best, for 30 minutes of every school day.

It is impossible for a school to call itself inclusive if they are set up to prioritise certain children over others. An inclusive school will ensure that every single child will have access to everything that happens in the school day. It means that if there are situations where this is a problem, systems are put in place to ensure that no child is made to feel unequal or to be treated differently because of their culture, identity or faith.

inclusiveBased on the first two questions alone, one could conclude that most Irish primary schools cannot be described as inclusive. While 85% of primary school teachers felt their schools were inclusive, 49% of primary schools surveyed have a Catholics-First enrollment policy. The 49% was divided into two parts: 20% who stated that, yes, their policy was to always enrol Catholics first and 29% who said that it wouldn’t be the case as they were never over-subscribed: however, if it ever happened, they would have to prioritise Catholics.

Faith formation must be provided for 30 minutes of a school day in denominational schools. Many teachers argue that they don’t ever fulfil this, which isn’t really the point – the fact they are supposed to provide 30 minutes of faith formation means that there are potentially 30 minutes in a school day, everyday, that a child outside that faith cannot access. This is 10% of every school day – almost 20 days of teaching time lost per year for a child who has been opted-out. However, the situation is even worse than this. As the ethos of a school permeates throughout the school day, there are other times where faith formation occurs, for example, prayers during the day. In the survey 90% of participants said that they said prayers outside of the discrete faith formation time. It was interesting to note that in that 90% there were 2 options: a harsh sounding: Yes – this is a Catholic School and a softer: Yes, but I make sure to let non-Catholics know they don’t have to join in. 40% of the answers were unapologetic about the school being a Catholic school. On asking the teachers what they would do if an opted-out child joined in the prayers, 62% said they would ignore it rather than deal with the situation, which in some ways I can understand, whether it is ethical or not.

ffishWhile schools have little control over enrollment policies and whether they provide faith formation or not, one thing they could probably do to ensure that children of no faith or minority faiths are as included as possible, would be to put discrete faith formation classes at the start or end of the school day. However, the survey showed that 85% of schools provide their faith formation classes in the middle of the day! While this is happening 84% of opted-out children have to stay in the classroom and do something else.

Catholic Schools’ Week is a difficult time for families who are not Catholic. One event that takes places more and more regularly is a special Mass for grandparents. Thankfully 63% of teachers claimed that they didn’t do this as it would exclude non-Catholic families. However, 1 in 3 teachers said that they simply invite all grandparents and it’s not really their problem if they show up or not.

The survey brought up other interesting tidbits surrounding RSE and homosexuality. It covered other events such as going to Mass and what happens if a child asked about an opted-out child. Answers were varied but overall, it was clear that despite all of the very obvious issues, Irish teachers still do not believe they are being anything but inclusive to non-Catholic children.

joinsinMy favourite question was based on Joanna Tuffy’s assertion that in her school, three Muslim girls took part in her children’s Catholic school’s Nativity Play. She claimed this was an example of how inclusive Catholic schools are. I don’t think I really need to break down why this is not inclusive and how it is actually offensive. The fact that the children’s families didn’t complain and complied did not mean that this was ok. However, in the survey nearly 1 in 5 teachers felt the same as Tuffy. Only 13% saw this as forced indoctrination, while the rest didn’t think it was either. I wish I had have put in an “other” option as I can’t think of any other way to describe this.

This survey demonstrates the true reality of what life is like for some children in Ireland’s primary schools and while the above is my analysis of it, I am sure others would disagree and claim that the above is either not happening or that I am being melodramatic. Some would even say that I am right and the answer is to open up more multidenominational schools but I don’t believe this is the answer either. I believe the answer is easier than this and, while it might take some time to achieve, it is definitely something that should be explored. In my next article, I am going to use the results of this survey to suggest how we can make schools more inclusive to everyone, including those who believe it is a right for them to have a religious school system.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe without commenting

Related Posts

alookactionplan
A Look at the Action Plan for Education

The Action Plan for Education was published today by Minister Richard Bruton. The government

30pointhandicap
Different points to enter Teacher Training College

RTE revealed that DCU's newly formed Teacher Training course, which amalgamated 3 previous colleges of

13533089_10153709592568848_8677493174608128982_n
Education Equality: Gathering for Change March

I was delighted and honoured to have had the opportunity to speak at the

cns-issue
What is the biggest issue for Community National Schools?

The Community National School model is being lauded as the ideal solution for primary education

cns
What’s the difference between the CNS model and the Catholic model?

Another government, another disappointing day for education. Jan O'Sullivan has left her mark and I

noreligion
Why Ticking “No Religion” Shouldn’t Matter in Schools

For people without a religion, the census always draws up conversation. Mostly, it's to do

congressintounion
INTO Congress: A Lesson in how to do Congress

The INTO congress was on this week. You might have missed it because you

ainclusive
How to make denominational schools more inclusive

Around 96% of Irish primary schools are under the patronage of a religious body,

untitled-report
Infographic of Survey on Inclusiveness

I developed an infographic based on the data received from my survey on how

inclusive
How inclusive are Catholic Schools?

Recently, The Irish Independent carried an article with the headline, Catholic Schools are as inclusive

religionge16
#GE16 and Primary Education: Religion in Schools

As we come up to the General Election, I'm looking at the various parties

league
Is it ethical to publish League Tables?

The Irish Independent published, what they called, a definitive league table of the best schools

mathchances
The Mathematics of Patronage and Pluralism

Between 96% and 98% of Irish primary schools are denominational in patronage, which means

2016prediction
2016 Predictions

As we come to the last day of year, it is traditional at Anseo.net to make predictions

rule68
What will removing Rule 68 actually do?

One of the rules of National Schools that has been causing much debate over

multidenominationalism
Multidenominational: A long word, long-abused

The education landscape used to be an easy one to maneuver. Between the 1920s

drakstain
Which dark stain will be removed in 2016?

Ask most teachers who the best education minister was and you'll most likely hear

erbe
Can the new NCCA Ethics Curriculum work in Ireland?

It always strikes me as odd the stories about primary education that get noticed

teacher
What are teachers for?

Michelle McBride writes about healthy eating in schools in her article called “It is

pluralism
Why Pluralism in Education Doesn’t Work

I was listening to a debate on the radio about the Angelus last week.

religionmaths
Media Focuses on Religion during Maths Week

There were a number of stories in the newspapers and media this week surrounding

waffle
Thoughts on the Digital Strategy

The Digital Strategy for Schools 2015-2020 is the latest attempt by the government to

1916
Should we be Celebrating the 1916 Rising?

Earlier this week, two army officials came to my school to present us with

capstone
An Alternative to Droichead

Following my blog post on Droichead last week, I thought I might expand on my

droichead
Droichead: A bridge too far

Droichead is a new model of induction and probation for newly qualified teachers, which

intonews
No wishes for pay equality from INTO

This week an email went out to all INTO members to welcome them back

burrenns
Burren National School: A symbol of the divestment process

Today, Educate Together announced that the proposed new Educate Together school in Castlebar was

unbaptised
Where do unbaptised children fit in?

I've been following the recent discussions about unbaptised children accessing primary education over the last

lra
Lansdowne Road Agreement: Vote Yes or No?

I usually have strong convictions about issues affecting the education system but I am

excited2
Who are the role models in primary schools?

Last weekend, I was part of a panel at the Excited Festival of Learning

classdojoireland
Anything to Gain from Gain Time? #DojoChatEU

I find it difficult to attend ClassDojo's chats every week so when this week's

yesvote
Why We’re Voting Yes to Marriage Equality

Commenting on referenda is not something that we generally do at Anseo.net but the

discriminate
Should schools be allowed to discriminate?

The headline grabber from the INTO congress was Jan O'Sullivan's announcement that new enrollment

intocongress
Ten Things to Keep in Mind at INTO Congress

Every year, during the spring holidays, the media takes an interest in education as the

ipads
Swapping Books for iPads?

The Irish Independent reported recently  that an anonymous donor had given a school in Fermoy, Co

wellbeing
Is all well with the new well-being guidelines?

In the last week, primary schools all received their first paper-based document from the

marriagequalityinto
Why the INTO need to support Marriage Equality

The campaign for marriage equality in May seems to be overwhelmingly supported by teachers

safeinternet
Safe Internet Day: Can one day save our children?

Today is Safer Internet Day and Webwise as usual are doing brilliantly, positive things

ncsecuts
One School’s Plea to the NCSE

The new proposed NCSE model is likely to be sanctioned very soon. I wrote

ippn15
IPPN 2015 Review

The annual IPPN conference, the largest educational conference in Ireland, where over 1,200 principals

marriageequality
Denominational Schools and the Upcoming Marriage Referendum

The upcoming referendum on marriage equality has sparked some conversation among teachers who work

cannonarticle
Why we don’t need to start teaching coding in primary schools

Ciaran Cannon is one of the most innovative politicians I know and he is

2014-11-06 15.50.56
Overwhelmed and Underwhelmed: Web Summit

I was delighted to get the opportunity to go along to the Web Summit

Creative Commons Some rights reserved (https://www.flickr.com/photos/cell105/142887353/)
Primary Schools and Broadband: The biggest issue in education today?

Following on from a conversation on the wonderful CESI list, I thought I would

beginning teaching
10 Educational Books that have stayed with me

Facebook is awash with challenges from ice-buckets to listing how you're grateful for the

religion
A short guide to religion in primary schools

Over the last number of years, the population of Ireland has changed. One of the

unhumanrights
Why we should care about Ireland’s Human Rights Record in Education

Last week, the Irish government was given a major slap on the wrist for

220px-Lucindacreighton
Who Jan O’Sullivan shouldn’t Hire as her Advisor

Jan O'Sullivan is our new Education Minister and, as a new member to the cabinet,

Ruairi-Quinn-390x285
Five more things the new Minister for Education should do…

Following on from Fintan O'Mahoney's excellent article, "Ten things the new Minister for Education

From Irish Independent
What will Ruairi Quinn’s Legacy be?

Minister for Education, Ruairi Quinn, announced his resignation today. The announcement was met with mixed

ncsereform
Is the NCSE reform even less equitable?

With much fanfare, the NCSE are reforming how resources are given to schools for

xpdead
What does the end of XP support mean for Irish schools?

If you walk into most primary schools, you'll find a vast array of different

www.ncca.ie
Draft Primary Language Curriculum Consultation:Your input needed!

Draft Primary Language Curriculum Consultation:Your input needed!I posted about the draft primary language curriculum

http://www.classroom-teacher-resources.com
INTO Congress: How should teachers behave?

Teachers are professionals in the same way doctors and lawyers are. Society expects professionals

Screenshot 2014-03-06 22.34.32
4 Problems with the new Anti-Bullying Procedures

The government's anti-bullying procedures are to be ratified in all schools before the 11th

Stad_Irish_stop_sign
Are schools to blame for us not speaking Irish? (#edchatie)

This week's chat on #edchatie on Twitter was very interesting and the subject of

https://www.google.ie/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&docid=N1JME6ZwtLFogM&tbnid=36OzYSowYhkl6M:&ved=0CAQQjB0&url=http%3A%2F%2Faboutbridgetmckenzie.wordpress.com
Fitness to teach is all about motivating teachers to love their job-Part 2

Self-actualisation and flowIn my first post on performance-related pay, I spoke about the process

From Irish Independent
Public Consultation for a new Digital Strategy for Schools

A couple of days ago, the Minister for Education, Ruairi Quinn, launched a public

Creative Commons from Wikipedia
Cutting the cost of school uniforms? Why not cut them altogether?

Irish parents are to be balloted on school uniforms in the coming weeks in

Image taken from Coláiste Lurgan: http://lurgan.biz/2012/10/5-steps-to-secure-gaeilges-future-in-the-education-system/
How to save the Irish language

One of the most popular conversations I have with non-teachers is about the Irish

Image:www.theliteracyshed.com
The Literacy Shed

In my free time, which isn't very much, I love, love, love writing and

Screen Shot 2013-10-13 at 15.15.38
Blog Awards show sharing breeds success

Last night I attended the Blog Awards in Naas. It was a glitzy affair,

Screen Shot 2013-08-07 at 21.34.06
Should Ask.fm be more socially responsible?

I'm currently asking some questions about social media in an attempt to see what

Image from Wikipedia
How will the new enrollment laws affect primary schools?

Ruairi Quinn has welcomed teachers back to school with new legislation surrounding enrollment in

Askfm
Shouldn’t we ensure Web 2.0 is not anonymous?

I'm currently asking some questions about social media in an attempt to see what

Screen Shot 2013-08-28 at 22.47.23
A Step towards Paper-Free Roll Books

The Department of Education were busy during the summer making some more circulars and

Screen Shot 2013-08-07 at 21.34.06
Should we ban children from using Ask.fm?

I'm currently asking some questions about social media in an attempt to see what

ask
Should we shut down Ask.fm?

Over the next couple of weeks, I'm asking some questions about social media in

Screen Shot 2013-07-27 at 00.12.24
JobBridge Controversy

JobBridge is a government internship scheme that that was designed to provide work experience

Aranho_U-turn_icon
Should we be happy with Quinn’s U-turn on Resource Hours?

Today, the minister for education, Ruairi Quinn reversed the most recent cut he had

NCSE_logo_03
Cutting through the latest spin on cuts to education

A day or so after the majority of primary school teachers decided to vote

teacher alone-body
Irish Primary Classrooms according to ERSC study:Not the best!

StudiesYesterday, you may have heard about a study from the ERCS has found that

photo credit: albertogp123 via photopin cc
Why Standardised Testing plans are rubbish

Last year, as part of the government's literacy and numeracy improvement plan, primary school

Screen Shot 2013-03-08 at 23.34.31
Before you vote on Croke Park 2…

Croke Park 2 has caused a lot of discussion in the teaching community. The

Image from http://curtisagency.com
Textbooks, Post Holders and Teacher’s Autonomy?

I trained to become a teacher in the UK back in 2002 after "teaching"

rollbook
The online rollbook is coming

Last week, at the IPPN conference, words that I never thought I would hear

Image from http://www.creditcards.com/
Wifi Warning or Scaremongering?

During the week, I received an email from an organisation called IDEA, with a

surface
Predictions for 2013

Last year we predicted that 2012 was going to be the year of the

2012
Anseo.net Review of 2012

Every December, we look back on the year and remember some of the highs

bell_curve
SSE: Shifting the Bell Curve

In my last article about the SSE (School Self-Evaluation), I wrote about how I

Image from: http://edusummit.info/
Couch Soundbite Doesn’t Sit Comfortably

There was something that grated on me when I saw the highly retweeted soundbite

Source: http://www.hutchnews.com/Todaystop/education-cuts-item-copy
Primary Education and the 2013 Budget

Ruairi Quinn has to make around €100m of cuts to the education budget today.

techfree
A Day Without Technology

Camara Education set a challenge to see if we could live without technology for

SchoolSelf-EvaluationIntroductionPrimarySchools-212x300
Thoughts after absorbing SSE

I'm largely in favour of the new School Self-Evaluation, (SSE), that was launched a

Gabriel Byrne is not a fan of the Gathering but that doesn't mean you can't be!
The Gathering Letter writing project

We all heard about the Gathering and we all probably heard Gabriel Byrne venting

suntimes-teachers
Do Teachers need Honours Maths?

 What does atan(y,x) do? If you did well in your Leaving Certificate Honours Maths

iwb-good
Should teachers be techies in 21st Century schools?

Following a very interesting tweet on last week's #edchatie, a contributor said that teacher

Screenshot from Irish Times article
Killing Primary Education

Back in October, The Irish Times ran a feature outlining the most influential people

interviewvideoconf1
Interviews via Video Conference

A few years ago I was asked an interesting question about whether it would

dawnedenirishtimes
Technology in Schools in the Dark Ages?

Great - another article damning schools and the Department of Education for failing the youth

Screen Shot 2012-04-10 at 12.54.49
INTO uses Social Media during Congress

It's good to see leadership in education. An example of this is in the

tcouncil
Do we need Teaching Council 2.0?

It hasn't been the best couple of months for the Teaching Council. Established six

IMAG0213
Best Schools? Another missed opportunity.

Sunday newspapers often feature supplements on different topics. This week the Sunday Business Post

puttnam
Technology and Pedagogy – not a chicken and egg

The IPPN conference is the biggest conference for primary school prinicpals in Europe with

Ruairi-Quinn-390x285
Something to think about Ruairi Quinn (Part 3)

The final part of my letter to Ruairi Quinn... Has there been any mention of

Ruairi-Quinn-390x285
Something to think about Ruairi Quinn (Part 2)

Continuing from my letter from the last day, here is part 2... Instead, in the

Ruairi-Quinn-390x285
Something to think about Ruairi Quinn (Part 1)

After attending the BETT conference in the UK, I experienced Michael Gove for the

ruairiquinn
Thoughts on Ruairí Quinn's Plan for Literacy and Numeracy

Ruairí Quinn has figured out how we can improve literacy and numeracy standards in

web20
Survey Results: Web 2.0 in Schools

As part of Anseo.net's competition to win a HD Flip Cam, participants answered some

moodle-logo
Should Moodle be used in Primary Schools?

Moodle is a tool for creating online courses and virtual learning environments (VLEs).  When

A Wordle image of Fine Gael and Labour's Education Policies
Labour – Fine Gael Education Programme

With a new government in place, a few decisions between the two parties had

positivity
What do Jedward and Positivity Week have in common?

There is a link, trust me.I am a member of the IPPN but that

sats
A Reaction to Falling Literacy and Numeracy Levels

I wanted to comment a bit on some of the proposals from the government

pisa2009
PISA reveals worrying results for Ireland

According to the research of PISA 2009, only 6.6% of students questions did not

photo
We need an update on kids' safety.

Here’s a transcript of Rozz's recent article published in the Think Tank section of

gaeilgecurriculum
ICT Grant = Demise of Gaeilge?

Recently, Irish primary schools were allocated a share of €25 million from the Department

teacherdesk
Where do you like to sit when you are the teacher?

The Desk at the top of the classroom! (and organisational settings for you to

techtools
Technology Upgraded, Teaching Downgraded?

I remember my first day at school vividly because everyone laughed at me.  My

digitalwatches
Douglas Adams, The Fourth R and Learning

I was happy to see that technology was on the agenda at the annual

CB058341
12 reasons to have Computerised Roll Books

Imagine it's 11:30am on June 30th.  What are you doing?  Apart from trying to

futuresource
International Study of Interactive Whiteboards

Last year I took part in an international study of Interactive Whiteboard use.

money
Saving Money for ICT

I came across a great article from Open Source Schools, a British web site,

vecwebsites
Why don't VEC primary schools have web sites?

If I want to find out about a school for a particular reason, the

tippinst
ICT in Education Conference 2010

Last year was the first year I attended the ICT in Education Conference in

computerroom
A Case for Computer Rooms

Computer rooms were on top of every primary school's wishlist back in the late

bullying
Social Networking and Bullying

With the news that Bebo may soon be no more,  I asked colleagues was

twitter-bird-pic
My Twitterversary

I've been using Twitter for a while now and am about to tweet for

whathavetheteachingcouncil
What have the Teaching Council ever done for us?

Have recently discovered Inside Education on 103.2 Dublin City FM. Simon introduced me to

ippn
Why IPPN works

I'm reading a fascinating book at the moment about how the net generation think,

spain
The brains of Spain are mainly very sane

I was sent a press release from Promethean Ireland entitled "Promethean Wins Major Spanish

penguins
Talkin' 'bout iGeneration

I'm a big fan of Conor Galvin, from UCD's school of education.  I have

techsupport
Technical Support in Schools (Irish Style)

We all know that primary schools are underfunded. We all know that the

smartschools
€150m for Smart Schools isn't smart at all

I feel that I should reiterate that I have deep concerns about the €150m

blogging
Why Blogging is Best – a digiteach article

I was asked to write a follow-up article about my workshop at this year's